The world of idol fandoms is a melting pot of passion, dedication, and occasionally, discord.
From the nostalgic first generation to the contemporary scene, each group has attracted its fair share of love and criticism.
A recent debate amongst fans has ignited conversations, questioning which fandom could be deemed the "worst" of all time.
SM Idols' Fandoms: Tradition or Transgression?
Netizens have voiced concerns about SM idols' fandom, citing it as a main offender throughout multiple generations.
One commentator remarked, "From the very first wave of idols, the SM fandom has been at the heart of many controversies."
IN CASE YOU MISSED IT: BTOB Minhyuk & (G)I-DLE Miyeon's Almost Kiss Shocks Audience - What's the Real Score Between Them?
This sweeping generalization, while potentially polarizing, taps into the long-standing issue of extreme behaviors within SM's group fandoms.
EXO-L: Fandom or Frenzy?
EXO-L, the fervent followers of EXO, also found themselves in the crosshairs of this lively debate.
One netizen emphatically singled out EXO-L, highlighting them as the fandom worthy of this unenviable title.
ARMY: Admiration or Aggression?
The fandom of global sensation BTS, famously known as ARMY, couldn't escape scrutiny either. "There's a wide consensus that it's ARMY," one participant shared.
A statement that may be seen as controversial given the worldwide love for BTS.
Multi-Generation Contenders: H.O.T., TVXQ, EXO, NCT
The generational torch of criticism, according to some, passes from HOT to TVXQ, then EXO, and now to NCT.
IN CASE YOU MISSED IT: aespa's 'Ugly' Pictures Becomes Controversial, Winter Criticized for Photo Editing
One observer commented, "For each generation-HOT in the 1st, TVXQ in the 2nd, EXO in the 3rd, and NCT in the 3.5th-it seems like the mantle of 'worst fandom' shifts."
ONCE: Influence or Interference?
Accusations of manipulation were leveled at ONCE, the fans of K-pop group TWICE.
"ONCE has a habit of swaying public sentiment via group discussions," one user shared, bringing another dimension to the debate.
NCT, aespa: Devotees or Disciples?
Some netizens suggested that followers of groups like NCT and aespa might be more than just fans-they could be seen as unwavering believers.
IN CASE YOU MISSED IT: Why is Everyone Still Looking Forward to EXO's Comeback?
This assertion raises questions about the fine line between devotion and obsession.
BLINK: Supporters or Sycophants?
BLINK, the fandom of BLACKPINK, wasn't exempt from criticism. Though the comment was brief, it echoed the sentiment of many in this conversation.
Each fandom, it seems, has its detractors. These differing viewpoints reflect the diverse and complex nature of idol fandoms.
But are these criticisms always justified, or do they only spotlight the behaviors of a few?
IN CASE YOU MISSED IT: aespa NingNing Trends After Savage Response to SujU Heechul's Provocative Remark on TV
However, as discussions grew more intense and divided, the original thread on Pann Nate discussing these fandoms was ultimately closed.
Yet, this has hardly put out the fire. The debates have spilled over into various corners of the internet, affirming that the exploration and evaluation of fandom culture remain as pertinent and controversial as ever.
Follow and subscribe to KpopStarz for more K-pop news and lists.
Cassidy Jones wrote this.
KpopStarz owns this article.
