Amid the backlash SHINee Taemin is receiving following his comeback album, "Guilty," his fandom Shawol defended the idol from accusations of sexual commercialization of minors.
SHINee Taemin Accused of Sexualizing, Voyeurism of Minors Following 'Guilty' Album Inclusions
In a women's online community, netizens complained about SHINee Taemin's solo comeback album, which allegedly includes photo cards that promote sexual commercialization.
Earlier on October 30, Taemin dropped his fourth mini-album, "Guilty." While the release itself performed well, some raised their brows at the physical album inclusions, which were sold in the form of an archive box.
A fan who purchased it particularly left a review on SNS which immediately went viral in the popular forum, saying:
"I see a boy through a hole... our eyes met. When I opened it, the boy was lying on the motel bed. Isn't this unhinged?"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/a63e0/a63e001020b2c9c61ec1e723127fd24720de9fd9" alt="Shawols Defend SHINee Taemin Against Sexualization of Minors Accusations"
In the photo released together, there was a hole on the outside of the box as if someone had pierced it, and the moment you sneak a peek from it, you'll make eye contact with Taemin's eyes lying on the bed.
The fan added:
"There were very suspicious photos in the zipper bag, so if you take it out, those were body parts of a boy. When I see it, I think about it. I wonder if I've really purchased the legitimate goods."
The photos in the zipper pack especially contain parts of Taemin's body, including close-up lips and waist.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7997b/7997be9112c8d021e76c3f7158b1c67b90c94010" alt="Shawols Defend SHINee Taemin Against Sexualization of Minors Accusations"
In particular, photos of slightly melted ice on his lips, including pants and undies that Taemin seemed to have taken off, drew attention.
As soon as female K-Netz saw these, they criticized Taemin's album and accused him of promoting the sexualization and voyeurism of minors, leaving comments such as:
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/422a7/422a7174bfe20d470fa07884fe52a5bbf62c31bb" alt="Shawols Defend SHINee Taemin Against Sexualization of Minors Accusations"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/1f94e/1f94e81004f9d4d21372eadfdcf45fe252ea1ba2" alt="Shawols Defend SHINee Taemin Against Sexualization of Minors Accusations"
"Even if you exclude everything else, the panties are really... It's a real 'guilty' that a large agency put out those and no one stopped them."
"It would be terrible if they were female idols."
"They think sexualizing of minors is attractive."
"The title 'Guilty' has a boyish concept and with a sexual connotation, it reminds me of pedophilia but combined with voyeurism, so I am very repulsed."
Shawols Defend Taemin from Sexualization Controversy
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4714e/4714eb1cb974088ec15bc34df503c80aa2cabf3f" alt="SHINee Taemin"
Meanwhile, Taemin debuted as the youngest member of the group SHINee in 2008 and began his solo career in 2014.
In SHINee, he was treated like the "baby" of the group, but he deviated from that image as a soloist.
After the accusations reached Shawols, SHINee's fandom, they were quick to defend the idol, pointing out the "hypocrisy" of K-Netz.
The idol's supporters explained that the whole point of the album is to instill "guilt" in fans who sexualized minor idols just like he experienced debuting at a young age, rather than promoting sexual commercialization.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4e32f/4e32f795aeb6ad4c120edb33cf66e9e57951c0ae" alt="SHINee Taemin"
Also, fans are frustrated that internet users were calling out the album's concept as voyeurism of minors when Taemin is already 30 years old and not a minor.
Shawols asked netizens to instead call out actual companies who were sexualizing underaged idols who were never addressed and a problem for the same K-Netz.
Here are some of what Shawols said:
mhj has been sexualising taemin since he was 14 and now that he’s claiming back his sexuality yall have a problem with it?? mind you these are the same people who have no problem when minors are debuting in the industry so don’t make me laugh with your hypocrisy https://t.co/utAjify1ZK
— rahima ᥫ᭡. (@choisrose) November 2, 2023
I'm reminded of the show they put underage Taemin in, putting the SHINee members against each other to win the affection of 20 something "noonas." Knetz were fine with that, but not with a 30-year-old reclaiming his sexuality and what he was put through at such a young age.
— 🌙Jjingu 🐰 SEXY IS IN THE AIR~ (@5hinee_whoyou) November 2, 2023
y'all don't even bat an eyelash when actual minors are being sexualized but when a 30 y/o man, whose solo career is where he gets to reclaim his sexuality, does a sexy concept (nothing new if u know him) it's suddenly controversial? stop projecting and leave taemin the fuck alone https://t.co/1J7hsNojPp
— yaya (@aekibum) November 2, 2023
which minors are these people talking about? I am so serious, WHICH MINORS?! THE ONLY MINOR HERE THAT WAS SEXUALIZED WAS TAEMIN AND NOW AS AN ADULT, HE IS TAKING CONTROL OF HIS OWN SEXUALITY AND YOU TWIST IT LIKE THIS?!
— isSHINeeback? (@isSHINeeback) November 2, 2023
For more K-Pop news and updates, keep your tabs open here at KpopStarz.
KpopStarz owns this article.
Written by Eunice Dawson.