Now that Coach is back in the loft, the boys will surely have exciting opportunities to have fun. Coach tells everyone that he's back in town after breaking up with his girlfriend. Jess is shocked and partly disheartened that Coach cannot remember her even if they literally lived together for two weeks.

Coach tells them that he wants to go to a strip club that's exclusively for boys. Jess does not fancy the idea but Nick tells Coach that it's fine since he still haven't talked to Jess about their "label".

Jess is apparently offended, that's why she enlists Cece's help in plotting revenge. Jess goes to the bar with her best friend who urges her to make Nick jealous. Cece suddenly remembers having the number of a guy named Artie.

Cece calls Artie but Jess tells the guy that she's taken. Realizing Cece's point that men in general cannot be trusted, Jess calls Artie again. Artie advises Jess to call Nick and sort things out. She did call Nick but he again made an offensive remark which prompted Jess to threaten him using Artie.

Back in the strip club, Nick and Schmidt plan to get Coach drunk since his behavior in the club is making them anxious. Nick finally realizes that he messed up. He tells Coach that Jess is amazing, that's why they need to return to the loft so that he can fix things. However, they stopped to beat the new beau of Coach's ex-girlfriend.

Cece freaks out when Jess decides to allow Artie to drive them home. On the other hand, a slap fights starts among Winston, Schmidt, Nick, and Coach. They stopped and ran away when the new boyfriend of Coach's ex-girlfriend went outside to look for them.

In the loft, Jess realizes her mistake and decides to tell Artie. However, she surprisingly finds Artie naked in her bed while seemingly refusing to leave. Nick comes home and sees the situation after Cece fails to distract him.

Fortunately, Nick believes Jess when she says that she did not intend to do anything bad. Nick gets rid of Artie and finally calls Jess his girlfriend.

Coach will be staying for the rest of the third season, that's why viewers have to watch out for the adventure that he'll be bringing in to the loft.